AVE Column “Small but Not Really” #3: Finding my way through racism

Small but Not Really is a column hosted by AVE, where we will try to help address your dilemmas about living as Asians in Europe. To kick things off, we’re sharing a query sent in by one of our own members. Do you have some helpful advice for them? Simply respond to this email and share your thoughts.

***

Finding my way through racism at work

Speaking up about a racist remark left me with difficult choices about my job and where to turn for support. Months later, I am still making sense of the hurt and learning how to stand up for myself.

It took me several minutes to speak. I was in a taxi with senior colleagues from my startup and the European representative of an Asian company we were working with. Everyone else carried on talking as I tried to work out how to respond to his racist remark.

I had joined our startup earlier that year. There were a little over twenty employees, nearly all white men, and the technical roles were staffed entirely by white men. As a queer Asian person assigned female at birth, I sometimes felt out of place. I wondered what people expected me to wear on a hike, when I should push to be noticed, whether I was being overlooked.

These were small uncertainties, part of settling into a new workplace. I was also beginning to feel a sense of belonging in Europe. What happened in the taxi and afterwards shook me more deeply than those earlier moments of feeling out of place, and I am still working through its effects.

In the taxi

The representative had come to our office for a meeting. He was not Asian himself. The partnership with the Asian company mattered a great deal to our startup, and our leaders had arranged meals and activities to make him comfortable.

During the social activities after the meeting, we took a taxi. He was joking about some Asian companies when he said, “ching chiang chong.” My mind went blank. My heart was racing, and for a while I could not work out how to respond.

I had been mocked in the street before, with people calling out “ni hao” or shouting the same sounds the representative had just used. Hearing them in this taxi put me in a situation I did not know how to handle. Several of the people in the car were senior leaders from my startup. Everyone except me was a white man. My colleagues kept talking and joking as though nothing had happened.

I felt deeply uncomfortable. I had spent my first months at the startup working hard and trying to build good relationships with my colleagues. If I spoke up now, I would have to interrupt the conversation and challenge the representative in front of the leaders who were trying so hard to please him. I did not know how they would respond, or what might happen if he took offence. Could it damage the partnership? Could there be consequences for my own job?

I wanted to say something, but I was afraid of the consequences. Staying silent was painful too. I knew I would not be able to sleep that night if I let the remark pass.

Several minutes went by while the others continued chatting. Eventually, I managed to calm myself enough to speak.

“I’m glad you came to our office today,” I said, “but what you just said was not okay.” He seemed startled that I had challenged him. He asked what the words meant, as though he did not understand. “They don’t mean anything,” I said. “They’re just words used to mock people.”

The car fell silent. After a while, a colleague found another topic. Conversation resumed, and we continued to our destination.

After I spoke up

A friend of mine worked for the same Asian company as the representative. When they asked how the visit to our startup had gone, I repeated exactly what the representative had said in the taxi. My friend was shocked and immediately decided to report the incident to their employer.

I did not hesitate to share what had happened. I had grown up believing that an employer ought to know when an employee behaved this way. Why would it be unreasonable for the Asian company to hear that its own representative had mocked Asian people? I could barely make sense of it. This was a man working for the Asian company, travelling at its expense, saying those words on a business visit.

I did not sleep that night.

The next morning, senior leaders at my startup called an emergency meeting and brought me into it. They talked over one another, telling me I should not have spoken to anyone outside our startup about the representative’s remark. I should not have let anyone report him, they said. They wanted me to stop the matter from going any further before it damaged the business relationship.

I had broken no law by telling my friend about the incident, and no policy at our startup prohibited me from doing so. I had believed that the Asian company ought to know how its representative had behaved. Now my own employer was treating my decision to tell someone as the problem I needed to fix.

The tone of one of the most senior executives at our startup troubled me, so I asked to speak with him alone. He told me I was too sensitive. It was just a joke, he said; he did not consider it racist. After that one-to-one meeting, I could not stop vomiting. I felt weak and was unwell for days.

It is difficult to write about that without feeling I have to explain how a few words could do so much harm. But by then, I had also been told that my objection was excessive and that I should not have spoken about what happened. Much of my distress came from having my experience and my feelings dismissed by people I had tried to talk to.

I met with the same executive several more times. He continued to insist that his view was right and that I should not tell others or complain. He questioned whether someone as sensitive as me could do work involving clients. “This time it’s racial discrimination,” he said. “What about next time, if it’s sexism, or some other kind of discrimination?”

I keep thinking about that question. To me, it turns the possibility of more discrimination into a test of whether I am capable of tolerating it. By the end of one of those conversations, I had all but promised to tell no one else and make no report.

Looking for support

I also tried to find help outside work. White friends were eager to help and told me about anti-discrimination offices in the city where I live. I contacted several. The offices advised me to do nothing. They could send a letter to my employer, but advised against it. They told me that the law would not protect me in a case of verbal abuse like mine, and warned that trying to pursue the matter could expose me to retaliation. I appreciated their honesty. I am still glad those offices exist. I understand their caution as an attempt to protect me from further harm, which is different from my bosses’ insistence on protecting a business relationship.

Still, I had gone looking for help and been advised against the action they could offer. My friends had somewhere to send me. The city had offices whose existence suggested that discrimination was taken seriously. Once I reached them, though, I was still left to decide how much more harm I could afford to risk.

This is where I struggle with the reassurance those services offer simply by existing. I can be grateful for the advice and still ask what protection was available to me. If the safest course was to swallow what happened, what was I supposed to do with everything it had left me feeling?

What I am still learning

I considered leaving. Without my income, I would have had to depend partly on my family, and I did not want to put that burden on them. I also could not understand why someone else’s wrongdoing should cost me my job. Leaving felt as though racism would have succeeded in driving me out.

Staying has its own discomfort. I still dislike that executive. I am still angry. Months later, I still sometimes wake in the night feeling powerless. Sometimes I feel ashamed that I have not fought harder or left. Knowing the practical reasons for staying has not stopped me questioning whether I should have done more.

Looking back, I can see how easily that questioning leaves out what I did try. I spoke in the taxi. I told my friend at the Asian company. I went back to the executive and sought help from several offices. When I ask whether I have done enough, I want to remember those efforts too.

I am still working out what standing up for myself can mean when the choices available to me carry costs I cannot easily bear. For now, I want to be able to say that I was hurt without first proving that I responded in the strongest possible way. I want to take my need for an income seriously without treating it as evidence that I did not take the racism seriously enough.

Even writing this, I worry that I am “trauma dumping”, filling space that could have held a more positive story. I am tempted to apologise for bringing readers feelings I have not resolved. Perhaps some of the pressure to keep this experience to myself has followed me into the act of writing about it.

What I do know is that I want to listen differently when someone tells me they have been hurt. I do not want to decide their experience was too small to matter, or make them defend the choices they made afterwards. I know how much damage that dismissal can add.

In the taxi, it took several minutes to find words I could say. Months later, I am still trying to give myself room to say what happened, including the parts I feel ashamed of. You are reading those words now. I want to let them reach you without an apology.

***

Small but Not Really is a new column hosted by AVE, where we share solutions to dilemmas about living as Asians in Europe, small and big alike. We will review all submissions, and ask that you refrain from sharing sensitive personal information (about you or anyone else). AVE retains the right to edit names, places, and other personally identifying information for publication. The focus of this column is to collectively brainstorm and share ways to deal with microaggressions and everyday racism, with the hope that it may also help other readers. This is not a platform for venting your feelings, or naming and shaming others. Please note that we will address selected stories from the perspective of fellow Asians who may have similar experiences and have lived in Europe for various amounts of time, not from the perspective of professionals in psychology, law, etc.

Author: R

Editor: Jiye

Image: Leh

Asian Voices Europe

Facilitating dialogue on racism against Asians in Europe.

Previous
Previous

[AVE Interview #4] Ann Li, co-founder of Untold Asian Stories

Next
Next

Asian Voices Europe withdraws from the European Commission-funded consortium ANTITHESIS